Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Search Properties

Start Your Real Estate Journey

Your go-to real estate team. We have brought together a team of experts equipped with knowledge and specialized experience to assist you in your buying and selling goals.

main

The Curated Difference

Staci and Amy believe buying or selling a home is rarely just a transaction—it’s a life transition. With deep Central Indiana roots and the perspective of raising their combined six children, they formed Curated Realty Collective to deliver a more thoughtful, supported experience.

They bring a calm, capable presence to every move, blending strategy, organization, and heart while managing details from start to finish. Their hands-on approach is backed by trusted vendors for prep, repairs, staging, and moving support. Complimentary pre-listing appointments replace overwhelm with a clear step-by-step plan, honest guidance, and zero pressure—so clients feel confident from start.

Why Berkshire Hathaway Home Services?

87.5%

Of Our BHHS Broker Partners Are Producing Agents - the Highest Percentage Among Top Brokerages in The State

Top 5 Largest Brokerage in State

BHHS Indiana Realty

1 out of 10

Homes Are Sold Through BHHS at All Price Points

2 out of every 10

Homes Are Sold Through BHHS Above $500k

1 out of every 4

Homes Are Sold Through BHHS Above $1 M

61% of homes sold

Currently in Bridgewater Have BHHS on One Side of The Transaction

3.4 out of every 10

Homes Have BHHS on One Side of The Transaction, Currently in Chatham

main

Meet Amy

With over 12 years of experience as a dedicated real estate agent in Indiana, I’ve had the privilege of helping buyers and sellers successfully navigate the real estate market and achieve their homeownership goals. My commitment to exceptional service, local market expertise, and strong client relationships has been the cornerstone of my career.

In addition to my work in real estate, I spent the last four years with a local lender, where I developed a deep understanding of the financing process. I gained hands-on experience with a wide range of loan products and financial tools—knowledge that now allows me to better guide my clients through every stage of the home buying journey with clarity and confidence

main

Meet Staci

Some moves are exciting. Others feel bittersweet. Others may feel overwhelming and stressful. Most are a little of all of those feelings — and that’s why having the right agent matters. I will bring calm, clarity, and steady support to the home buying and selling process, so clients feel confident in their decisions and cared for along the way.

My experience in Indiana real estate spans multiple areas, including multi-family, property management, moving specialist services, and residential real estate. That range gives me a practical, detail-driven perspective — and a real understanding of what it takes to prepare a home, manage a timeline, advocate for my clients, and navigate the emotions that come with change.

I grew up in Cicero near Morse Reservoir, and have proudly called Fishers home for 25 years. Home has always meant more to me than an address — it's a feeling and a chapter of your life. I would be honored to help you move into your next chapter with intention and confidence.

 
 

Testimonials

Brandi M.

Brandi M.

I've used Amy Gallagher to both buy and sell my home. I greatly appreciated her guidance throughout the buying process as I was a first-time homebuyer at the time. Her expertise was extremely helpful and turned an otherwise str...
Read More
Jill C.

Jill C.

Working with Amy was an outstanding experience. She was knowledgeable, responsive, and made the home-buying process smooth and stress-free. We felt supported every step of the way and truly appreciated her attention to detail a...
Read More
Jimmy S.

Jimmy S.

Amy did an amazing job, and we would recommend her for any and all potential buyers or sellers. From start to finish, she made the home-buying and selling process smooth, stress-free, and even enjoyable. Her deep knowledge of t...
Read More
Christina & John

Christina & John

We have bought and sold several properties over the years and are repeat clients of Amy Gallagher. She is extremely knowledgeable, professional, and proactive in addressing issues. Amy is also very personable and responsive to ...
Read More
David H.

David H.

Amy was a great resource to work with, very knowledgeable on both sides of the sale, and the closing with the mortgage company, very responsive, helped with staging and resources to get things fixed on the new house and the hou...
Read More

How Much is Your Home Worth?

  • Instant property valuation
  • Expert advice
  • Sell for more

Work With Us

Curated Realty Collective is dedicated to helping you find your dream home and assisting with any selling needs you may have. Contact them today for a free consultation for buying, selling, renting, or investing in Indiana.

Follow Me on Instagram